HARS: Heuristic-Enhanced Adaptive Randomized Scheduling for Concurrency Testing

Concurrency programs often induce buggy results due to the unexpected interaction among threads. The detection of these concurrency bugs costs a lot because they usually appear under a specific execution trace. How to virtually explore different thread schedules to detect concurrency bugs efficiently is an important research topic. Many techniques have been proposed, including lightweight techniques like adaptive randomized scheduling (ARS) and heavyweight techniques like maximal causality reduction (MCR). Compared to heavyweight techniques, ARS is efficient in exploring different schedulings and achieves state-of-the-art performance. However, it will lead to explore large numbers of redundant thread schedulings, which will reduce the efficiency. Moreover, it suffers from the “cold start” issue, when little information is available to guide the distance calculation at the beginning of the exploration. In this work, we propose a Heuristic-Enhanced Adaptive Randomized Scheduling (HARS) algorithm, which improves ARS to detect concurrency bugs guided with novel distance metrics and heuristics obtained from existing research findings. Compared with the adaptive randomized scheduling method, it can more effectively distinguish the traces that may contain concurrency bugs and avoid redundant schedules, thus exploring diverse thread schedules effectively. We conduct an evaluation on 45 concurrency Java programs. The evaluation results show that our algorithm performs more stably in terms of effectiveness and efficiency in detecting concurrency bugs. Notably, HARS detects hard-to-expose bugs more effectively, where the buggy traces are rare or the bug triggering conditions are tricky.