First Order Optical Interference between Distinguishable Photon Paths

A necessary condition in order to obtain interference fringes in QED is the existence of at least two possible paths and unknown which-path information. If the photon beams have different frequencies, stability of the sources and fast enough detectors are also required. In this experiment, first order interference between two truly independent CW Nd:YAG monomode laser sources was produced. Contrary to what is expected, interference is observed although the photon beams are distinguishable and the path is unequivocally known for each photon beam. Segments of the ultra-stabilized CW wavetrains are selected with an acousto optic modulator. Temporal and spatial interference are integrated in a single combined phenomenon via streak camera detection. In this way, interference fringes and frequency beating are both present in the streak camera images. The photon beams are labeled with two slightly different frequencies. In addition, the inclination of the beams establish the projection of their respective wave vectors in the detection plane, which may be seen as perturbations coming from two different slits. The fringes displacement in the time-space interferograms reveal the trajectories of the frequency labeled photons. Since the detection probability of any one photon is independent from the detection of the rest, the trajectory can be drawn for each frequency labeled event. These results indicate that in non-degenerate frequency schemes, the ontology has to be refined and the which path criterion must be precisely stated. If reference is made to the frequency labeled photons, the path of each photon is known, whereas if the query is stated in terms of the detected photons, the path is unknown.