Investigation for Performances Comparison PI, Adaptive PI, Fuzzy Speed Control Induction Motor for Centrifugal Pumping Application

Among the total energy consumed by presently installed utilities, pumping systems contributes nearly 30% of them that are controlled through induction motor. The flow rate of centrifugal pump is directly proportional to the speed of induction motor. Induction motor based electric drives are a complex nonlinear system to control due to their varying nature of speed with respect to changes in load. Thus, controllers are required for the speed control and performance enhancement of the induction motors. In this paper, a comparison of various controllers is discussed for the flow rate control of the pumping system. Among all the conventional controllers the proportional integral derivative (PID) is the mostly preferred for induction motor speed control. However, high overshoot, fixed gain constants and sluggish response are the disadvantages of the PID controller. So, automatic gain tuned PI controllers (i.e., adaptive PI controllers) are introduced to overcome the drawbacks of the conventional PID controllers. Further advancements in the field of artificial intelligence lead to the development of fuzzy logic based controllers. These controllers are simple, compatible and can be modelled without detailed mathematical model of the system. Thus, they are gaining more popularity than other controllers. The rules and membership functions (MFs) are responsible for performance of fuzzy logic controllers are designed using trial and error method. The result comparison of all the controllers is presented and the performance of each controller is analyzed. From the observations, fuzzy logic controller provides better performance than the conventional controllers.