Noise Analysis and Comparison of Phase- and Frequency-Detecting Readout Systems: Application to SAW Delay Line Magnetic Field Sensor

Transmission surface acoustic wave (SAW) sensors are widely used in various fields of application. In order to improve the limit of detection (LOD) of such sensor systems, it is essential to understand and quantify the relevant noise sources. Only then, strategies for noise reduction can be developed. In this paper, low noise readout systems for the application with SAW sensors in open-loop and closed-loop configurations are presented and experimentally investigated with regard to their phase noise on the example of a SAW delay line magnetic field sensor. Besides a comprehensive analysis of the phase- and frequency modulated signals, respectively, previously derived equations in a theoretic study for describing the LOD of both readout structures are utilized in the experimental context. According to the theory, the same LOD is also obtained in the experiment for all frequencies for which the noise contributions of the readout electronics are negligible. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first experimental study that directly compares both operating modes for the same sensor and in terms of the overall achievable LOD. The results are applicable to all kinds of phase-sensitive delay-line sensors.