Effects of Real Instrument on Performance of an Energy Detection-Based Spectrum Sensing Method

In cognitive radio (CR) networks, the role of spectrum sensing (SS) is crucial to enable an efficient exploitation of the radio spectrum resource. The need to measure spectrum occupancy turns CRs to be
de facto
measurement instruments, so it becomes crucial to analyze how real instrumentation peculiarities could affect performance in spectral measurements (i.e., SS performance). In this paper, a commercial software-defined radio (SDR) is adopted as cognitive device, and its capability to accurately measure occupied spectrum is analyzed in comparison also with a simulation setup, where the same analog-to-digital converter (ADC) is modeled and simulated, and equivalent signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) are replicated. To this aim, a suitable experimental setup has been designed, metrologically characterized, and tuned. Experimental results prove how nominal SNR typically adopted for testing the performance of SS methods is not sufficient to model the impairments of a real acquisition chain, even jointly with a modeling of the digitization process. To assure a reliable SS method validation, new approaches have to be considered for enhancing the accordance between the performance predicted in the simulation environment and the experimental one reachable on real devices. Since different architectures of CRs are present on the market, the experimental tests should be preferred for a reliable SS performance assessment.