Comparison Analysis of Google Maps, Wisepilot, and Here Wego With User-Centered Design (UCD) Approach & Cartography

Application testing is measured from the user's point of view by highlighting five aspects of testing, which are functionality, effectiveness, efficiency, reliability, usability, and cartography. This research aims to make a comparison between Google Maps, Here Wego, and Wisepilot applications on the Android operating system as a better alternative that should be used in searching locations on maps and navigation routes through user satisfaction testing. Applications in this test are used in the recommended navigation routes and locations in Malang which requiring several types of testing on each application. For each application is tested and evaluated by five aspects of testing using Web Quality Evaluation Method (WebQEM) method and cartography rules. The writer has analysed and made a comparison of test results that were conducted on each aspect based on the standard assessment categories in each aspect tested. The Google Maps application is superior to other three applications based on four of the five aspects tested: functionality, effectiveness, efficiency, reliability, usability.