An experimental comparison of GaN, SiC and Si switching power devices

This paper presents an experimental switching behaviour comparison of GaN HEMT and SiC MOSFET against their Si competitors, the Si SJ MOSFET and high speed Si IGBT, in the 650 V class. The devices are first compared using their respective datasheets. The test circuit is introduced and hard switching tests under inductive load are performed to reveal the switching performance of the devices. The differences in the switching behaviours of the devices are identified and discussed.