How Developers Document Pull Requests with External References

Online resources of formal and informal documentation-such as reference manuals, forum discussions and tutorials-have become an asset to software developers, as they allow them to tackle problems and to learn about new tools, libraries, and technologies. This study investigates to what extent and for which purpose developers refer to external online resources when they contribute changes to a repository by raising a pull request. Our study involved (i) a quantitative analysis of over 150k URLs occurring in pull requests posted in GitHub, (ii) a manual coding of the kinds of software evolution activities performed in commits related to a statistically significant sample of 2,130 pull requests referencing external documentation resources, (iii) a survey with 69 participants, who provided feedback on how they use online resources and how they refer to them when filing a pull request. Results of the study indicate that, on the one hand, developers find external resources useful to learn something new or to solve specific problems, and they perceive useful referring such resources to better document changes. On the other hand, both interviews and repository mining suggest that external resources are still rarely referred in document changes.