Performance Comparison of Doubly Salient Reluctance Machine Topologies Supplied by Sinewave Currents

This paper comprehensively investigates the electromagnetic performance of 3-phase, 12-slot, and 8-pole switched reluctance machines (SRMs) with different winding configurations, i.e., double/single layer, short pitched (concentrated), and fully pitched (distributed). These SRMs are supplied by sinewave currents so that a conventional three-phase converter can be employed, leading to behavior which is akin to that of synchronous reluctance-type machines. Comparisons in terms of static and dynamic performances such as d- and q-axis inductances, on-load torque, torque-speed curve, and efficiency map have been carried out using two-dimensional finite-element method (2-D FEM). It is demonstrated for the given size of machine considered that for same copper loss and without heavy magnetic saturation, both single- and double-layer mutually coupled SRMs (MCSRMs) can produce higher on-load torque compared to conventional SRMs (CSRMs). Additionally, double-layer MCSRM achieved the highest efficiency compared to other counterparts. When it comes to single-layer SRMs, they are more suitable for middle-speed applications and capable of producing higher average torque while lower torque ripple than their double-layer counterparts at low phase current. Two prototype SRMs, both single layer and double layer, are built to validate the predictions.