Evaluation of Spaceborne L-Band Radiometer Measurements for Terrestrial Freeze/Thaw Retrievals in Canada

The landscape freeze/thaw (F/T) state has an important impact on the surface energy balance, carbon fluxes, and hydrologic processes; the timing of spring melt is linked to active layer dynamics in permafrost areas. L-band (1.4 GHz) microwave emission could allow the monitoring of surface state dynamics due to its sensitivity to the pronounced permittivity difference between frozen and thawed soil. The aim of this paper is to evaluate the performance of both Aquarius and soil moisture and ocean salinity (SMOS) L-band passive microwave measurements using a polarization ratio (PR)-based algorithm for landscape F/T monitoring. Weekly L-band satellite observations are compared with a large set of reference data at 48 sites across Canada spanning three environments: 1) tundra; 2) boreal forest; and 3) prairies. The reference data include in situ measurements of soil temperature (Tsoil) and air temperature (Tair), and moderate resolution imaging spectroradiometer (MODIS) land surface temperature (LST) and snow cover area (SCA) products. Results show generally good agreement between L-band F/T detection and the surface state estimated from four reference datasets. The best apparent accuracies for all seasons are obtained using Tair as the reference. Aquarius radiometer 2 (incidence angle of 39.6°) data give the best accuracies (90.8%), while for SMOS, using the Aquarius temporal characteristics, the best results (87.8% of accuracy) are obtained at higher incidence angles (55°-60°). The F/T algorithm identifies both freeze onset and end with a delay of about 1 week in tundra and 2 weeks in forest and prairies, when compared to Tair. The analysis shows a stronger F/T signal at tundra sites due to the typically clean transitions between consistently frozen and thawed conditions (and vice versa) and the absence of surface vegetation. Results in the prairies were poorer because of the influence of vegetation growth in summer (which decreases the PR) and the high frequency of ephemeral thaw events during winter. Freeze onset and end maps created from the same algorithm applied to SMOS and Aquarius measurements characterize similar F/T patterns over Canada. This study shows the potential of using L-band spaceborne observations for F/T monitoring, but underlines some limitations due to ice crusts in the snowpack, liquid water content in snow cover during the spring freeze to thaw transition, and vegetation growth.