Comparison of Usability of Oxide Apertures and Photonic Crystals Used to Create Radial Optical Confinements in 650-nm GaInP VCSELs

Threshold characteristics of GaAs-based 650-nm gallium indium phosphide (GaInP) vertical-cavity surface-emitting diode lasers (VCSELs) with two different optical confinement structures are investigated with the aid of a self-consistent, fully- physical VCSEL model. Efficacy of the optical confinement introduced by the oxide aperture is compared with an alternative single-defect photonic-crystal design with holes etched throughout the whole VCSEL. Initially, photonic-crystal VCSEL reveals 10% lower threshold electrical power than that of the analogous oxide-confined VCSEL. Further optimization of the current injection allows for an additional 20% threshold reduction. The photonic-crystal confinement concept appears to be a very prospective solution for VCSEL configurations, for which oxidation is unfeasible, e.g., for possible nitride or phosphide VCSELs.