Combinatorial Power Flow Analysis using Adiabatic Quantum Algorithms

We investigate the performance of different annealers for power flow analysis. The annealers are D-Wave’s simulated annealer Neal, D-Wave’s quantum-classical hybrid annealer, D-Wave’s Advantage™ system (QA), Fujitsu’s simulated annealer, and Fujitsu’s digital annealer V3 (DA). We implement Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) and Ising model formulations, with the latter offering finer control over complex voltage adjustments. We also propose a new method for the iterative and adaptive updating of complex voltages for the QUBO and Ising model formulations. Six different test systems are experimented with. QA and DA show superior performance over classical annealers. DA effectively manages the 15-bus system, whereas QA encounters difficulties in embedding the problem graph onto the hardware graph because of the limited qubit connectivity. This constraint confines QA to the 14-bus system with the QUBO formulation and the 4-bus system with the Ising model formulation. The best performance is associated with different annealers across different test systems, which suggests that adjusting the threshold can improve precision if the compiler and annealer are capable of handling the variables involved.