The Comparative Study of Artificial Intelligence Techniques: DeepMotion vs. Autodesk Maya in Enhancing 3D Animation Creation and Learning Experiences

This study investigates the effectiveness of traditional software (Autodesk Maya) versus AI-powered tools (DeepMotion) in the creation of 3D animations, focusing on learner engagement, personalized learning, and performance outcomes. The research employs a quasi-experimental design with a mixed-methods approach, combining action research and surveys. Sixteen purposively selected participants with baseline knowledge in digital arts were assessed using a Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practices (KAP) framework before and after engagement with both tools. The study defines efficiency in terms of time and quality, comparing the ability of Autodesk Maya and DeepMotion to produce high-quality animations efficiently. Results indicate that Autodesk Maya produces higher-quality animations, while DeepMotion significantly reduces time utilization, making it almost ten times more efficient than Maya (efficiency scores of 0.896 vs. 8.609, respectively). Two-sample t-tests reveal statistically significant differences (p < 0.01) in both quality and time efficiency between the two tools. These findings highlight the complementary strengths of each tool—Maya's superior quality versus DeepMotion's time efficiency—suggesting that the choice of software should align with user priorities, whether emphasizing animation detail or production speed.