Analysis of Energy Intensity and Generic Energy Efficiency Metrics in Communication Networks: Limits, Practical Applications, and Case Studies

Energy intensity is the ratio between energy consumed and data volume over a certain time frame. It is frequently used as a metric to indicate the energy efficiency of communication networks and data centres for the provision of digital services, and as a coefficient to apportion the total energy consumption of a network to a specific service. As energy efficiency becomes more important, energy intensity metrics are increasingly used to estimate the energy costs and benefits of changes in data volumes across networks and data centres. Typically, energy intensity integrates annual accounts of energy consumption and data transmitted. At shorter time scales, this metric is affected by the lack of correlation between transmitted data and energy consumption, which leads in some cases to inappropriate conclusions. In this work, we first review the use of energy efficiency metrics in the literature. Then, we define generic measures for energy efficiency as well as energy intensity. The relationships of those measures are analysed, and we show under which conditions they lead to the same or different results. Practical applications of the measures and their insights are demonstrated when benchmarking systems and when considering the value of the system’s output. Furthermore, the limits and pitfalls of the metrics are analysed, especially considering the energy intensity metric for communication networks.