Automating GUI-based Test Oracles for Mobile Apps

In automated testing, test oracles are used to determine whether software behaves correctly on individual tests by comparing expected behavior with actual behavior, revealing incorrect behavior. Automatically creating test oracles is a challenging task, especially in domains where software behavior is difficult to model. Mobile apps are one such domain, primarily due to their event-driven, GUI-based nature, coupled with significant ecosystem fragmentation.This paper takes a step toward automating the construction of GUI-based test oracles for mobile apps, first by characterizing common behaviors associated with failures into a behavioral taxonomy, and second by using this taxonomy to create automated oracles. Our taxonomy identifies and categorizes common GUI element behaviors, expected app responses, and failures from 124 reproducible bug reports, which allow us to better understand oracle characteristics. We use the taxonomy to create app-independent oracles and report on their generalizability by analyzing an additional dataset of 603 bug reports. We also use this taxonomy to define an app-independent process for creating automated test oracles, which leverages computer vision and natural language processing, and apply our process to automate five types of app-independent oracles. We perform a case study to assess the effectiveness of our automated oracles by exposing them to 15 real-world failures. The oracles reveal 11 of the 15 failures and report only one false positive. Additionally, we combine our oracles with a recent automated test input generation tool for Android, revealing two bugs with a low false positive rate. Our results can help developers create stronger automated tests that can reveal more problems in mobile apps and help researchers who can use the understanding from the taxonomy to make further advances in test automation.CCS CONCEPTS• Software and its engineering → Software maintenance tools; Software testing and debugging; Software usability.