An Exploration of State-of-the-Art Automation Frameworks for FPGA-Based DNN Acceleration

FPGA-based acceleration is considered a promising approach to improve the performance and power efficiency of Deep Neural Network (DNN) inference tasks. However, mapping a DNN onto an FPGA is not trivial. To make this easier, various automation frameworks have been proposed. Among them, FINN and Vitis AI, both developed by Xilinx, are two key players. They represent two different philosophies in designing FPGA-based DNN accelerators: dataflow-style and overlay-style architectures. Dataflow architectures are generally expected to provide better performance and power efficiency but have a major drawback in that they scale very poorly to the size of the target DNN. Advanced frameworks like FINN alleviate this drawback by transforming the target DNN into operations that can be time-multiplexed on fewer hardware resources. This approach, however, is challenging because of the difficulty in transforming the target DNN and raises a question as to whether the generated dataflow architectures retain a significant advantage over overlay architectures in terms of performance and power efficiency. This paper aims to clarify it by conducting an in-depth exploration of FINN and Vitis AI. For this purpose, we extend the FINN’s development flow to be able to use the same target hardware and DNN model to evaluate each framework. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the FPGA-based acceleration by providing a comparison with two reference platforms: an NVIDIA Jetson Nano Developer Kit with a similar power budget to our target FPGA hardware, and a high-performance desktop computer with an Intel Core i7-11700K CPU. The results show that despite the use of the time-multiplexing approach, the FINN-based accelerator can still outperform the Vitis-AI-based accelerator by a significant margin, 8.4x in terms of latency, 3.0x in terms of throughput, and 3.3x in terms of power efficiency. The outcome of the comparison with the NVIDIA Jetson Nano Developer Kit and the desktop computer is also overwhelmingly favorable to the FINN-based accelerator. This indicates that, even in the case of using automation frameworks, DNN accelerators on FPGAs can still yield significant performance and power efficiency gains compared with GPUs and CPUs.