Low-cost, rapidly deployable emergency mechanical ventilators during the COVID-19 pandemic in a developing country: Comparing development feasibility between bag-valve and positive airway pressure designs

The COVID-19 pandemic disrupted the world by interrupting most supply chains, including that of the medical supply industry. The threat imposed by export restriction measures and the limitation in the availability of mechanical ventilators posed a higher risk for smaller, developing countries, used to importing most of their technologies. To actively respond to the possible device shortage, the initiative "Ventilators for Panama" was established and was able to develop two different, non-competing, open-source hardware mechanical ventilator models for emergency use in case of shortages: one based on a bag-valve design and another based on positive airway pressure. The aim of this article is to compare both devices in terms of feasibility and functionality. Results from the functional testing show that both devices perform within specification, as the error percentage is lower than 5% for the desired pressure values and a standard deviation of less than 0.5 for all cases.Clinical Relevance— This study shows the feasibility of quickly deploying two different mechanical ventilator designs for emergency use and their effectiveness.