Comparative Study of Wound-Field Flux-Switching Machines and Switched Reluctance Machines

In this paper, comparisons between two permanent-magnet-free machines, namely a wound-field flux-switching machine (WFFSM) and a switched reluctance machine (SRM), are carried out. The topologies and operation principles of the WFFSM are illustrated first. Then, the effects of rotor skewing angle on static characteristics, e.g., open-circuit phase flux-linkage and back electromotive force due to field currents, electromagnetic torque, and torque ripple, have been investigated in depth by finite-element analysis (FEA). Consequently, the optimal rotor skewing angle is determined. After that, comparisons at the rated speed 1500 r/min and at the rated RMS current density of 5 A/mm
²
among the 6-armature-slots/5-rotor-poles (6/5) straight- and skewed-WFFSMs, and two representative SRMs, namely conventional 12/8 SRM and the short-flux 12/10 SRM with the same stator outer diameter and stack length are conducted in terms of phase flux-linkage, inductance, and torque performance. The results indicate that for these two PM-free machines, at the rated speed and the rated RMS current density, the skewed-rotor WFFSM exhibits considerably larger torque capacity, much smaller torque ripple, stronger saturation withstand ability. In addition, the experiments of the skewed-WFFSM and the 12/8 SRM prototypes working at the mechanical character curve are conducted. The experimental results present that the power factor of the WFFSM is much higher and the efficiency is slightly lower than that of the 12/8 SRM.