How do ALOHA and Listen Before Talk Coexist in LoRaWAN?

In this work we address the analysis of a LoRaWAN network where some devices access the channel according to the standard-compliant ALOHA protocol, while other devices transmit according to a Listen Before Talk paradigm based on the CSMA/CA mechanism. To analyze this scenario, we propose a mathematical model to obtain the Data Extraction Rate both for CSMA/CA and ALOHA devices, as well as the average delay experienced by messages transmitted by CSMA/CA devices. Simulation results show the accuracy of our model, as well as the benefits of introducing CSMA/CA devices into the network, even when not all the devices implement this mechanism and must coexist with ALOHA devices.