Incorporation of adaptive mutation based on subjective evaluation in an interactive evolution strategy

A rapidly emerging model in the field of adaptive computing is the symbiosis of human expertise with evolutionary algorithms for user controlled and directed search. The two aspects in any EA are the selection of individuals to reproduce based on some measure of their quality or fitness and the application of variation operators to produce new solutions. In the context of interactive evolution, these aspects are compounded by the need for rapid convergence to prevent user fatigue and to provide the user some control over the generation of new solutions. Elsewhere, in the work of the authors (2004), we have examined different policies for best incorporating the user into the evaluation and selection process. In this paper, we explore the hypothesis that user assigned fitness represents a source of information that can be used to control the variation process: effectively to broaden the search if none of the current solutions is promising, or focus the search and improve convergence speed in the vicinity of a good solution. The main aims of this study, therefore, are to analyse the advantages of using a user directed adaptive mutation strategy over fixed mutation step sizes in terms of time to converge and robustness of the resulting solution. We present results showing a qualitatively different type of search process can be obtained by using the user assigned fitness to control the nature of the mutation process. There is also a synergy between user-based selection and fitness-based mutation control which out performs either system on its own.