Assessing the Freeze–Thaw Dynamics With the Diurnal Amplitude Variations Algorithm Utilizing NEON Soil Temperature Profiles

Accurately determining the freeze/thaw state (FT) is crucial for understanding land–atmosphere interactions, with significant implications for climate change, ecological systems, agriculture, and water resource management. This article introduces a novel approach to assess FT dynamics by comparing the new diurnal amplitude variations (DAV) algorithm with the traditional seasonal threshold algorithm (STA) based on the soil moisture active passive (SMAP) brightness temperature data. Utilizing soil temperature profiles from 44 sites recorded by the National Ecological Observatory Network between July 2019 and June 2022. The results reveal that the DAV algorithm demonstrates a remarkable potential for capturing FT signals, achieving an average accuracy of 0.82 (0.89 for the SMAP–FT product) across all sites and a median accuracy of 0.94 (0.92 for the SMAP–FT product) referring to soil temperature at 0.02 m. Notably, the DAV algorithm outperforms the SMAP-adopted STA in 25 out of 44 sites. The accuracy of the DAV algorithm is affected by daily temperature fluctuations and geographical latitudes, while the STA exhibits limitations in certain regions, particularly those with complex terrains or variable climatic patterns. This article's innovative contribution lies in systematically comparing the performance of the DAV and STA algorithms, providing valuable insights into their respective strengths and weaknesses.