No-Reference Segmentation Annotation Quality Assessment

Image segmentation tasks aim to separate the image into masks that represent different objects or regions, where deep-learning-based methods have become mainstream. In the common practice, researchers utilize large-scale datasets including images along with their annotations to train their models, and evaluate the predictions with evaluation metrics. However, to our knowledge, no metrics have been proposed to assess the quality of the segmentation annotations, which will bring benefits to both the labeling and experimental process. In this paper, we fill this research gap and propose the first no-reference segmentation annotation quality assessment named SAQ. Based on our observation, we utilize the normal gradients of pixels on the annotation contours to represent the degree of fitting the real contours, which reflect the annotation accuracy. To alleviate the image differences, we adopt the gradient ranking score rather than directly using the gradient value. The multi-scale strategy is introduced to accommodate annotations of objects with different structures. Extensive experiments on datasets for various segmentation tasks have demonstrated the rationality of our proposed SAQ, and the assessment results of their annotation quality can serve as significant references for researchers.