By Topic

IEEE Quick Preview
  • Abstract



We report here on the progress made in 2012 in the broad field of organic photonic sensors (OPSs). This paper does not intend to be exhaustive of the whole subject but aims at giving an overview of very recent trends in use of organic functional materials for optical sensing. More specifically, we focus our attention on the exploitation of OPSs in two emerging and attractive fields: chemical sensing and coupling to living tissues for biological applications. Section 1 highlights results reported on photonic crystals (PCs), distributed-feedback (DFB) lasers, optical fibers, and molecule-functionalized nanoobjects. Section 2 sheds light on the emerging field of organic bioelectronics, focusing in particular on the realization of photodetectors able to work in a bio-like environment.



2.1. PCs

PCs are the optical analogs of electronic semiconductor crystals since, in these systems, a periodicity in refractive index along one, two, or three spatial dimensions comparable with optical wavelengths generates photonic band gaps, while point, line, bend, and planar defects give rise to intragap states that enable localization, guiding, and trapping of light.

2.1.1 One Dimension

One-dimensional porous PCs are very interesting materials, due to their easy fabrication and their exploitation for many applications, as lasers and switches [1], [2]. For sensing application, the fabrication of 1-D PCs, based on microporous metal–organic framework (MOF) material layers and mesoporous titanium dioxide layer, has been shown. The peculiarity of Zeolitic imidazolate framework ZIF-8 is molecular selectivity, while mesoporous Formula$\hbox{TiO}_{2}$ has been employed to ensure high refractive index contrast and to guarantee molecular diffusion within the whole PC. Sorption behavior of the photonic material was studied as a function of partial pressure of organic vapors, resulting in a good sensitivity and selectivity toward a series of chemically similar solvent vapors. For methanol vapor, with this sensor, a steep increase in the photonic band-gap shift is already observed at a partial pressure of 0.1 [3].

2.1.2 Two Dimension

Li and Lotsch, in April 2012, showed a stimuli-responsive 2-D PC based on a monolayer inverse opal of polyelectrolyte gel. A remarkable feature of this monolayer inverse opal is that it holds tunable photonic properties despite a submicron thickness. For this reason, the photonic sensing for solutes does not suffer from slow diffusion and the response can be greatly sped up. As P2VP is well known as a weak cationic polyelectrolyte that exhibits fast and substantial swelling under acidic conditions due to protonation of the pyridine group, a pH sensor based on this 2-D photonic structure is demonstrated, showing a band-gap shift of 6, 15, and 29 nm to pH 5, 4, and 3, respectively [4].

2.1.3 Three Dimension

3-D ordered inverse-opal films bearing a reactive trifluoroacetyl group have been successfully constructed. Through the specific reaction between cyanide and trifluoroacetyl, these photonic films can selectively detect, at a submicromolar level, cyanide by a shift of the photonic band gap [5]. Pan et al. [6] synthesized a polyacrylamide inverse-opal hydrogel (IOHPAM) film by in situ polymerization in a polystyrene colloidal crystal template. The IOHPAM shows periodically ordered interconnecting porosity, giving rise to a photonic band gap (with reflectivity up to 80%). The IOHPAM film exhibits a rapid reversible change, in volume and in refractive index, in response to alcohol. For this reason, the structural color of the IOHPAM film quickly changes with these changes. The reflection peak of the IOHPAM film shows blue or red shifts that depend on the structure of the alcohols. The extent of the shift depends on the number of -OH groups and on chain length, structure, and concentration of the alcohols. Photonic band-gap shifts of several nanometers are observable at 10% methanol solutions. The IOHPAM film is also sensitive to polyethylene glycol (PEG), displaying different blue-shift responses to PEGs with different molecular weights.

2.2. DFB Lasers

DFB lasers are a type of laser where the feedback mechanism is provided by a photonic structure in which the active material is embedded or in close contact.

A process that combines polymer nanoreplica molding with horizontal dipping has been proposed to fabricate large-area (approx. Formula$3 \times 5\ \hbox{in}^{2}$) DFB laser biosensors (DFBLBs) on flexible plastic substrates, which have been subsequently incorporated into standard format 96-well microplates (see [7], Fig. 1). A room-temperature nanoreplica molding process has been employed to fabricate subwavelength periodic grating structures, while a horizontal dipping process was used to apply a dye-doped polymer film of about 300 nm. The DFBLB emission wavelength, used to characterize the device uniformity, demonstrated a coefficient of variation (CV) of 0.41%. The fabricated sensors have been also characterized for sensitivity uniformity by measuring the bulk refractive index of the media exposed to the sensor surface and by measuring adsorption of biomolecular layers. An assay for detection of the cytokine Tumor Necrosis Factor-alpha (TNF- Formula$\alpha$) has been used to demonstrate the operation of the sensor in the context of label-free detection of a disease biomarker. The lowest TNF-Formula$\alpha$ concentration measured with this system has been 0.625 Formula$\mu\hbox{g/mL}$, comparable with previously measured values obtained by dual color fluorescence cross-correlation spectroscopy [8]. The demonstrated capability represents an important step toward roll-to-roll manufacturability for very sensitive biosensing [7].

Figure 1
Fig. 1. Schematic of a DFBLB structure (a) and Lorentz fitted spectrum of DFB laser emission. The blue curve was measured when the sensor surface was exposed to PBS, while the red curve shows the laser spectrum after application of the anti-TNF-a capture molecules (reprinted with permission from [7]).

Organic PC and DFB laser sensors are very interesting since they are easy to fabricate and versatile for a wide range of analyte detection. Organic DFB lasers have been demonstrated to inherently be very sensitive taking advantage of the criticality of stimulated emission phenomenon. However, these kind of lasers need to be optically pumped.

2.3. Optical Fibers

Miniaturized optical relative-humidity (RH) sensor based on a polymer-infiltrated PC fiber interferometer has been demonstrated [9]. The sensor shows a high sensitivity to RH variations with a change in its reflected power of about 12 dB for a humidity change of 84% RH. The sensor has the advantages of a very compact length of 1 mm, and an end-type probe configuration makes it suitable for monitoring humidity in microenvironments (for example, with respect to fiber bends [10] and long period gratings [11]). The response time of the sensor is found to be 400 ms for a change in RH of Formula$\sim$30%. The fast response time suggests that the sensor can potentially be used as a human breath rate monitor in a clinical situation (e.g., during magnetic resonance imaging scan because of its immunity to magnetic-field interference).

Yuan et al. [12] have shown stable wavelength tunable inscription of polymer optical fiber Bragg gratings (FBGs). By straining the fiber during FBG inscription, the center wavelength over 7 nm can be linearly tuned with less than 1% strain. Above 1% strain, the tuning curve saturates, resulting in a maximum tuning of 12 nm with 2.25% strain.

2.4. Functionalized Nanoobjects

Porphyrin-functionalized ZnO nanorod photoconductivity (under visible-light illumination) change has been reported [13], modulated by exposure to two volatile organic compounds, ethanol and triethylamine (chosen as model analytes). The sensitivity to triethylamine exceeds that to ethanol by more than two orders of magnitude, showing a selectivity that is not found in other porphyrin-based gas sensors, higher with respect to other types of porphyrin-based gas sensors [14].

The synthesis of luminescence-quenched shell cross-linked nanoparticles as photonic nanoprobes for protease sensing has been recently shown. Proteases are overexpressed in most cancers and proteolytic activity has been shown to be a viable marker for cancer imaging in vivo. Protease sensing scheme is based on a “turn-on” mechanism where the protease cleaves peptide cross-linkers of the fluorescence-quenched shell cross-linked NP (off-state) leading to a highly emissive noncross linked NP (on-state). The cross-linked particles can be strained by exposure to a good solvent and proteolysis allows for particle expansion (swelling) and a recovery of the luminescence [15].

2.5. Genomics and Proteomics

In 2012, diverse organic optical sensors, in the area of genomics and proteomics, have been described. Nyberg et al\. [16] demonstrated a single-step method to obtain a DNA barcode, visualized using nanofluidic devices and fluorescence microscopy. Using a mixture of YOYO-1, a bright DNA dye, and netropsin, a natural antibiotic with very high AT specificity, DNA map with a fluorescence intensity profile along the DNA that reflects the underlying sequence has been obtained. Compared with other existing barcoding techniques, such method is single step, the barcode is formed already in the test tube, and only commercially available molecules have been employed.

Seefeld et al. [17] have shown on-chip protein synthesis/capture methodology to create a protein microarray from a double-stranded DNA microarray in a microfluidic format that can be used immediately for surface plasmon resonance imaging biosensing measurements. Such microarray needs only Formula$10^{-14}$Formula$10^{-15}$ moles of DNA for its operation.

The coordination complex terpyridine-Formula$\hbox{CuCl}_{2}$ has been demonstrated to be an efficient fluorescent sensor for histidine, an essential amino acid for human growth, in aqueous solution [18]. The system is very sensitive since, in presence of Formula$10^{-4}\ \hbox{M}$ of L-hystidine, the complex emission increased 700 times with respect to the initial value.



The most advanced OPS has been realized by the thousand-year work of the natural evolution, and this is the eye. Historically, there have been many attempts to reverse engineering the human visual system in order to reproduce its amazing characteristics for various applications, such as light sensing, robotic systems, imaging, biomedical research, and development of artificial visual implants. Scientists have developed many bio-inspired systems, based on different materials, mainly inorganic semiconductors. Only very recently, organic semiconductors have started attracting attention for the realization of artificial photonic sensors, due to their specific advantages: intrinsic bioaffinity with natural systems, excellent mechanical and biocompatibility properties, ability to conduct both electrons and ions, low-cost and simple processing technologies, and intrinsic sensitivity to visible light allowing for a trichromatic system [19], [20], [21]. For all these reasons, semiconducting polymers are optimal candidates for the realization of biologically inspired artificial visual systems and even retinal prosthetic implants.

In the field of visual imaging applications, the organic technology represents a much more cost-effective approach, as compared with existing device fabrication techniques. Highly sensitive polymer photodetectors and image sensors have been extensively demonstrated in different configurations, able to work both in the visible and in the near IR, covering wide sensing areas also on flexible substrates. Last year, a novel hybrid organic/inorganic imager device has been reported, in which semiconducting polymers, deposited by low-cost spray coating techniques, replace the silicon photodiodes and cover a conventional CMOS-pixel array as a continuous film, without further structuring [22]. In this case, the imager works on a grayscale. Color sensitivity is usually obtained by adopting two possible approaches, either by using three detectors sensitive to different spectral regions, or, more commonly, by coupling a monochromatic detector to an array of color filters. An original work by Narayan and coworkers [23] reported the fabrication of a single-polymer pixel array yet capable of multicolor sensing. The smart design does not require any color filtering and works without external bias; instead, it is based on an appropriate thickness of the active polymer layer that results in a characteristic polarity and temporal profile of the photovoltage signal in response to various incident colors. Interestingly, the authors highlight nice similarities between the device characteristics and certain biological systems, such as purple membrane proteins, photosynthetic membranes with chlorophyll and, even more strikingly, mammalian retinas. The device structure comprises here an anodic contact made by indium–tin oxide, covered by a bulk heterojunction photovoltaic blend, in direct contact with a saline electrolyte, thus closely resembling a bio-like environment. Indeed, many other conjugated polymers (including regioregular poly(3-hexylthiophene-2,5-diyl), rr-P3HT, poly-[N-90-heptadecanyl-2,7-carbazole-alt-5,5-(40,70-di-2-thienyl-20,10,30-benzothiadiazole), PCDTBT, poly(3-octylthiophene), P3OT, poly(9,9-dioctylfluorene-co-benzothiadiazole, F8BT, poly[2-methoxy-5-(2-ethylhexyloxy)-1,4-phenylene-vinylene], MEH-PPV, poly[2-methoxy-5-(3 Formula$^{\prime}$, 7Formula$^{\prime}$-dimethyloctyloxy)-1,4-phenylene vinylene], MDMO-PPV, poly [2,6-(4,4-bis-(2-ethylhexyl)-4Hcyclopenta[2,1-b;3,4-b Formula$^{\prime}$]-dithiophene)-alt-4,7-(2,1,3 benzothiadiazole)], PCPDTBT) have been demonstrated to work as active layers in direct contact with saline aqueous solutions and biological media, such as saline buffers and culturing media [24], [25]. Based on this same configuration, the realization of a polymer-based electrochemical cell for water splitting applications has been recently proposed [26]. A photocatalytic semiwater splitting reaction, leading to hydrogen evolution, occurs at the polymer surface, directly contacted to the saline solution, as a consequence of visible-light generated photocurrent. The device absolves thus a twofold function, acting both as a photocatalytic and a photovoltaic system.

The most appealing application of the hybrid polymer/liquid light-sensitive interface is perhaps in the neuroscientific and biomedical fields. It has been demonstrated that an organic photovoltaic blend [namely P3HT doped with (6,6)-phenyl-C61-butyric acid methyl ester], with PCBM, deposited on a transparent ITO conducting layer is able to elicit upon photostimulation electrical activity in primary neurons grown on top of it [27]. The high spatial and temporal resolutions of the photoexcitation, together with the good biocompatibility properties demonstrated for the organic semiconductors, open the way to potential applications in the field of retinal prosthetics. The goal here is to restore photosensitivity in retinas whose natural photoreceptors are damaged or lost. Very recently, Ghezzi et al. [28] reported that such bioorganic interface, working in photovoltaic conditions and minimally invasive, is capable of restoring light sensitivity in ex vivo blind retinas, at levels indistinguishable from those of healthy control retinas. Interestingly, dose-response measurements revealed a threshold intensity for the photostimulation of about 0.3 Formula$\mu\hbox{W/mm}^{2}$, closely matching the range of retinal irradiance during outdoor activity (0.1–10 Formula$\mu\hbox{W/mm}^{2}$). The reported results demonstrate that organic semiconductor represent a valuable and reliable alternative to the more traditional devices used for retinal implants, thus opening the way to a fully unexplored application of OPSs.


Corresponding author: F. Scotognella (e-mail:


No Data Available


No Photo Available

F. Scotognella

No Bio Available
No Photo Available

G. Lanzani

No Bio Available
No Photo Available

M. R. Antognazza

No Bio Available

Cited By

No Data Available





No Data Available
This paper appears in:
No Data Available
Issue Date:
No Data Available
On page(s):
No Data Available
INSPEC Accession Number:
Digital Object Identifier:
Date of Current Version:
No Data Available
Date of Original Publication:
No Data Available

Text Size