Evaluation of existing Harmonic-to-Noise Ratio methods for voice assessment

In this paper, an evaluation of several methods allowing the estimation of the Harmonic-to-Noise Ratio (HNR) of sustained vowels was conducted. The HNR estimation methods are mainly based on time, spectral, and cepstral signal representations. An algorithm was implemented for each method and was tested with synthesized voice sounds in order to evaluate their accuracy. Tests were also conducted with real pathological voice sounds in order to evaluate the behaviour of the different methods under real conditions.