By Topic

Comparing verification systems: interactive consistency in ACL2

Sign In

Cookies must be enabled to login.After enabling cookies , please use refresh or reload or ctrl+f5 on the browser for the login options.

Formats Non-Member Member
$33 $13
Learn how you can qualify for the best price for this item!
Become an IEEE Member or Subscribe to
IEEE Xplore for exclusive pricing!
close button

puzzle piece

IEEE membership options for an individual and IEEE Xplore subscriptions for an organization offer the most affordable access to essential journal articles, conference papers, standards, eBooks, and eLearning courses.

Learn more about:

IEEE membership

IEEE Xplore subscriptions

1 Author(s)
W. D. Young ; Comput.. Logic Inc., Austin, TX, USA

Achieving interactive consistency among processors in the presence of faults is an important problem in fault tolerant computing, first cleanly formulated by L. Lamport, R. Pease, and M. Shostak (1980; 1982) and solved in selected cases with their Oral Messages (OM) algorithm. Several machine supported verifications of this algorithm have been presented, including a particularly elegant formulation and proof by John Rushby using EHDM and PVS (S. Owre et al., 1992, 1995; J. Rushby, 1992). Rushby proposes interactive consistency as a benchmark problem for specification and verification systems. We present a formalization of the OM algorithm in the ACL2 logic and compare our formalization and proof to his. We draw some conclusions concerning the range of desirable features for verification systems. In particular, while higher order functions, strong typing, lambda abstraction, and full quantification have some value they come with a cost; moreover, many uses of such features can be easily translated into simpler logical constructs, which facilitate more automated proof discovery. We offer a cautionary note about comparing systems with respect to a small set of problems in a limited domain

Published in:

IEEE Transactions on Software Engineering  (Volume:23 ,  Issue: 4 )