The commenters offer a counterexample to the results presented by W. Yue (see ibid., vol.39, no.6, p.818-22, June 1991) concerning the effect of capture on multichannel slotted ALOHA. A simplified deterministic capture is assumed by Yue. Numerical results show that the actual average throughput is much higher than that obtained by Yue for the same parameters.<
Published in:
Communications, IEEE Transactions on
(Volume:41
,
Issue:
10
)
Date of Publication: Oct. 1993