A comparison of trellis modules for binary convolutional codes

A convolutional code can be represented by the conventional trellis module or the "minimal" trellis module based on the BCJR trellis for block codes. For many convolutional codes, the trellis complexity (TC) of the minimal module is significantly less than the TC of the conventional module. An alternative representation, consisting of an extended BCJR trellis module and a pruned version of the conventional module, was previously introduced. We prove that the overall TC of the two new modules is less than the TC of the conventional module for infinitely many codes. Furthermore, we show that the overall TC of the new modules is smaller than the TC of the minimal module for many codes considered in the literature.