Modeling of Reaction Forces in High-Voltage Substation Structures

When designing utility substations, it is necessary to consider all directional components of the electromagnetic reaction forces during short-circuit faults to properly account for their effects on substation equipment. IEEE 605 assumes straight long parallel conductors in its two-dimensional (2-D) force calculations while ignoring any bends and 3-D placement of conductors. CIGRE's Brochure 105 provides practical information on the mechanical effects of short-circuit currents in HV and EHV open air, conventional substations. Although these computational methods are easy to implement, they have several limitations and are sometimes too conservative. Previously published papers address such conservatism using dynamic analysis approaches that provide more accurate results when compared to experimental data. This paper provides two extensions to IEEE 605 and CIGRE 105 for calculating fault current reaction forces. A closed-form equation defining the simplified 2-D short-circuit force time history during a fault based on CIGRE 105 and a computationally inexpensive numerical 3-D force calculation technique are presented.