Thermal-mechanical Co-design of Cold Plate, Second Level Thermal Interface Material (TIM2) and Heat Spreaders for Optimal Thermal Performance for High-end Processor Cooling

Cooling high-end system processors has become increasingly more challenging due to the increase in both total power and peak power density in processor cores. Junction peak temperature at worst case corner conditions often establish the limits on the maximum supportable circuit speed as well as processor chip yield. While significant progress has been made in cooling technology (e.g., cold plate design and thermal interface materials at first and the second level package), a systematic approach is needed to optimize the entire thermal and mechanical stack to achieve the overall (optimal) thermal performance objectives. The necessity and importance of this is due to the thermal and mechanical design interdependencies contained with the overall stack. This paper reports an in-depth study of the thermal-mechanical interactions associated with the cold plate, second level thermal interface material (TIM2) and heat spreaders. Thermal test results are reported for different cold plate designs and TIM2 pad sizes. Thermal and mechanical modeling results are provided to quantify the TIM2 thermal performance as a function of the TIM2 mechanical stress, the TIM2 dimensions and cold plate design. As described via both modeling and testing results, an optimal TIM2 pad size results as a trade-off between heat transfer area for conduction and TIM2 compressive pressure. In addition, pressure sensitive film study results are also provided revealing that heat spreader design affects the module level and TIM2 thermal performance. Results from this set of work clearly demonstrate the close interactions between cooling hardware in the stack hence the importance of thermal-mechanical co-design to achieve optimal thermal performance for the high-end processors.