iPAWS: Instruction-issue pattern-based adaptive warp scheduling for GPGPUs

Thread or warp scheduling in GPGPUs has been shown to have a significant impact on overall performance. Recently proposed warp schedulers have been based on a greedy warp scheduler where some warps are prioritized over other warps. However, a single warp scheduling policy does not necessarily provide good performance across all types of workloads; in particular, we show that greedy warp schedulers are not necessarily optimal for workloads with inter-warp locality while a simple round-robin warp scheduler provides better performance. Thus, we argue that instead of single, static warp scheduling, an adaptive warp scheduler that dynamically changes the warp scheduler based on the workload characteristics should be leveraged. In this work, we propose an instruction-issue pattern-based adaptive warp scheduler (iPAWS) that dynamically adapts between a greedy warp scheduler and a fair, round-robin scheduler. We exploit the observation that workloads that favor a greedy warp scheduler will have an instruction-issue pattern that is biased towards some warps while workloads that favor a fair, round-robin warp scheduler will tend to issue instructions across all of the warps. Our evaluations show that iPAWS is able to adapt to the more optimal warp scheduler dynamically and achieve performance that is within a few percent of the statically determined, more optimal warp scheduler. We also show that iPAWS can be extended to other warp schedulers, including the cache-conscious wavefront scheduling (CCWS) and Memory Aware Scheduling and Cache Access Re-execution (MASCAR) to exploit the benefits of other warp schedulers while still providing adaptivity in warp scheduling.