Design and Performance Comparison of Vernier and Conventional PM Synchronous Wind Generators

In recent years, the permanent magnet vernier machine (PMVM) has attracted much attention in the research community. Many studies have shown that PMVMs possess superior torque density and are suitable for high-torque and low-speed applications. Some of them compared PMVMs with the direct-drive permanent magnet synchronous machines (PMSMs), but these studies focused mainly on sub-kW power levels. There is little work in the literature that conducted the comprehensive evaluation of PMVM technology for more specific applications. This article presents the design optimization of a 15-kW surface-mounted PMVM and its comparison with an equivalent conventional PMSM for wind generator applications. It attempts to objectively weigh the relative merits of the two wind generator systems and outline their respective advantages and disadvantages. For validation purposes, an optimally designed 15-kW PMVM was constructed and experimentally evaluated, which is one of the largest PMVM prototypes ever reported in the literature. It shows that the PMVM can be a competitive alternative to the PMSM for this application.