Investigating the Relationship Between Satellite-Based Freeze/Thaw Products and Land Surface Temperature

This paper investigates surface temperature variables as they relate to passive microwave-derived surface freeze/thaw (FT) state and assesses the accuracy of such FT products relative to surface temperature. Utilizing retrievals from the soil moisture active/passive (SMAP), advanced microwave scanning radiometer, and special sensor microwave imager instruments, surface FT records have previously been derived globally. Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer skin temperature, North American Land Data Assimilation System (NLDAS) skin, 0–10-cm soil layer, and 2-m air temperatures are compared to the various FT state products (FTSPs) by defining the threshold for FT state transitions at 0 °C. This paper utilizes the 2015–2016 overlap period in FT records within the NLDAS domain. Spatial variability of classification accuracy (CA) is then investigated over the study area. A proportional differencing method also enables the identification of biases between FTSPs and surface temperature variables. Additionally, by analyzing probability distribution functions of FTSPs associated with temperature values, we assess the distribution of temperature variables as they relate to FT classifications. Classification agreement is shown to vary with sensor configuration, seasonality, and retrieval time. Air temperature is found to have the highest CAs across FTSPs (81%–91%), while NLDAS soil exhibits a close relationship to FTSPs, especially in regard to SMAP products. Finally, ascending (
p.m.
) retrievals are shown to be increasingly linked to the selected temperature parameters as compared to descending (
a.m.
) observations. This paper contributes to an improved understanding of current FTSPs and will benefit efforts to enhance future FT products.