Scale-space properties of quadratic feature detectors

We consider the scale-space properties of quadratic feature detectors and, in particular, investigate whether, like linear detectors, they permit a scale selection scheme with the "causality property", which guarantees that features are never created as the scale is coarsened. We concentrate on the design of one dimensional detectors with two constituent filters, with the scale selection implemented as convolution and a scaling function. We consider two special cases of interest: the constituent filter pairs related by the Hilbert transform, and by the first spatial derivative. We show that, under reasonable assumptions, Hilbert-pair quadratic detectors cannot have the causality property. In the case of derivative-pair detectors, we describe a family of scaling functions related to fractional derivatives of the Gaussian that are necessary and sufficient for causality. In addition, we report experiments that show the effects of these properties in practice. We thus demonstrate that at least one class of quadratic feature detectors has the same desirable scaling property as the more familiar detectors based on linear filtering.