Comments on "Coaxial probe modeling in waveguides and cavities" [with reply]

For the original article see ibid., vol. 40, p.2172-80 (1992). The commenters state that in the aforementioned paper, Liang et al. presented an excellent analysis of a coaxial probe in waveguides and cavities. The compact dyadic Green's function technique was applied there to calculate the electric field. However, they point out some typographical errors of the dyadic Green's function components in the paper which will mislead further investigations. These errors are listed and corrections given. In reply the authors welcome the comments and also point out a further error for which the correct form is given.<
>