Comments on "Properties of electromagnetic beams generated by ultra-wide bandwidth pulse-driven arrays" [with reply]

The commenter maintains that there are some errors in the above-titled paper by R.W. Ziolkowski (see ibid., vol.40, no.8, p888-905, Aug. 1992) that may affect some results and the conclusion of the paper. Ziolkowski replies that the commenter's analysis is incorrect and does not reproduce experimentally known results, because of an incorrect model of the receiver corresponding to the matched transmitter. Ziolkowski presents further analysis in support of this condition.<
>