<sitemesh:write property='title'/>Response to "Comment on 'A Novel Data Distribution Technique for Host-Client Type Parallel Applications" | IEEE Journals & Magazine | IEEE Xplore <meta name="bingbot" content="nocache"> <meta property="twitter:title" content="Response to "Comment on 'A Novel Data Distribution Technique for Host-Client Type Parallel Applications"" /> <meta property="og:title" content="Response to "Comment on 'A Novel Data Distribution Technique for Host-Client Type Parallel Applications"" /> <meta property="twitter:description" content="Our rebuttal statement is in two parts. A. Generic rebuttal: the area of scheduling is very active with more than 3,000 papers published over this decade alone in good journals. In addition, Krishna and Shin note, in 1997 itself, that the number of papers in the area seems to have increased exponentially since 1970. As a consequence, it is rather difficult to get a handle on all of them.. The records indicate that several aspects of our work appear to be very contemporary to the works of some of the other's work cited by the author. This goes to show that more than one person can have the similar approach to solving similar problems. B. Technical rebuttal: the work quoted by Sohn et al. (1998) deals with the analysis of heterogeneous CPUs. In particular, with the analysis of minimizing the cost (as in $) by selecting the lowest selection of CPUs available that will finish a job in a given time frame. They also analyze the minimum time as well for a given selection of CPUs. Their timeline shows all processes finishing at the same time and does not take into account applications that transfer result data, which our paper does." /> <meta property="og:description" content="Our rebuttal statement is in two parts. A. Generic rebuttal: the area of scheduling is very active with more than 3,000 papers published over this decade alone in good journals. In addition, Krishna and Shin note, in 1997 itself, that the number of papers in the area seems to have increased exponentially since 1970. As a consequence, it is rather difficult to get a handle on all of them.. The records indicate that several aspects of our work appear to be very contemporary to the works of some of the other's work cited by the author. This goes to show that more than one person can have the similar approach to solving similar problems. B. Technical rebuttal: the work quoted by Sohn et al. (1998) deals with the analysis of heterogeneous CPUs. In particular, with the analysis of minimizing the cost (as in $) by selecting the lowest selection of CPUs available that will finish a job in a given time frame. They also analyze the minimum time as well for a given selection of CPUs. Their timeline shows all processes finishing at the same time and does not take into account applications that transfer result data, which our paper does." /> <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary" /> <meta property="twitter:image" content="https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/assets/img/ieee_logo_smedia_200X200.png" /> <meta property="og:image" content="https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/assets/img/ieee_logo_smedia_200X200.png" /> <script src="https://cmp.osano.com/AzyzptTmRlqVd2LRf/6fda1518-2a1e-4b5b-a049-da0bef71dcab/osano.js"></script> <link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cookie-consent.ieee.org/ieee-cookie-banner.css" type="text/css"/> <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html;charset=utf-8" /> <meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=Edge"> <g:compress> <link rel="stylesheet" href="/assets/css/simplePassMeter.min.css?cv=20240416_000000" /> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="screen, print" href="/assets/dist/ng-new/styles.css?cv=20240416_000000"/> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="screen, print" href="/assets/dist/ng-new/customStyles.css?cv=20240416_000000"/> <link rel="stylesheet" href="/assets/vendor/swiper/dist/idangerous.swiper.css?cv=20240416_000000"> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" media="screen, print" href="/assets/css/jquery-ui-1.8.19.custom.css?cv=20240416_000000"/> </g:compress> <script type='text/javascript'> var googletag = googletag || {}; googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || []; (function() { var gads = document.createElement('script'); gads.async = true; gads.type = 'text/javascript'; var useSSL = 'https:' == document.location.protocol; gads.src = (useSSL ? 'https:' : 'http:') + '//securepubads.g.doubleclick.net/tag/js/gpt.js'; var node = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; node.parentNode.insertBefore(gads, node); })(); </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="/assets/vendor/jquery/jquery-3.5.1.min.js?cv=20240416_000000" charset="utf-8"></script> </head> <body class="body-resp"> <div id="global-notification" class="row stats-global-notification"> <div class="hide u-hide-important col Notification Notification--global Notification--fixed"> <a href class="Notification-close js-close" aria-label="close message button"><i class="fa fa-close"></i></a> <div class="Notification-header"></div> <div class="Notification-text"></div> </div> </div> <div id="LayoutWrapper"> <div class="row"> <div class="col"> <div class="Header" id="xplore-header" data-service="true" data-inst="false" data-web="false" style="display:none"></div> <div id="global-alert-message"></div> <meta name="cToken" content="eyJhbGciOiJIUzUxMiIsInppcCI6IkRFRiJ9.eNqqVkosKFCyUoooyMkvSlXSUcosLgZyK2Dc1AqgrKG5oYmBiYmBqTFQPrEEJmBobGpcCwAAAP__.89LXk1_88keVNaNjYoAu7wq_zG7MGCo7zltqDU1tEHRpS1RNnSz3m0rQnwzZwHQQCtMXtfTmPTRa_U7vIwb87g"> <script type="text/javascript"> document.write('<base href="/document/" />'); </script>  <script type="text/javascript" src="https://scholar.google.com/scholar_js/casa.js" async></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://app.cadmoremedia.com/Scripts/Embed.js"></script>  <script type="text/javascript" src="https://app.cadmoremedia.com/Scripts/PicturePop.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> var body_rightsLink ="", body_publisher = ""; var recordId = ""; var AUTHOR_PROFILE = 'ON'; if (AUTHOR_PROFILE.toUpperCase() == "OFF"){ var AUTHOR_PROFILE_ENABLED = false; }else{ var AUTHOR_PROFILE_ENABLED = true; } var xplGlobal = { document: { disqus:{ remote_auth_s3 : '', public_api_key:'1lxKgMbpNIbQvfk2tqLcWeSVloE8rgIY2CV1tCu3Vp641oL4eEITYBbkViJJGNYY', short_name:'ieeexplore', client_url:'https://ieeexplore.ieee.org', sso_enabled:'{$sessionProfile.provisioned}' }, fullTextAccess: false, isAccessFromInstitution: false } }; xplGlobal.document.metadata={"userInfo":{"institute":false,"member":false,"individual":false,"guest":false,"subscribedContent":false,"fileCabinetContent":false,"fileCabinetUser":false,"institutionalFileCabinetUser":false,"showPatentCitations":true,"showGet802Link":false,"showOpenUrlLink":false,"tracked":false,"delegatedAdmin":false,"desktop":false,"isInstitutionDashboardEnabled":false,"isInstitutionProfileEnabled":false,"isRoamingEnabled":false,"isDelegatedAdmin":false,"isMdl":false,"isCwg":false,"isReadAndPublish":false,"isIel":false,"isAcademic":false},"authors":[{"name":"N. Comino","affiliation":["Discipline of Computer Science and Software Engineering, University of Newcastle, Callaghan, Australia","The University of Newcastle, Callaghan, NSW, AU"],"firstName":"N.","lastName":"Comino","id":"37991841500"},{"name":"V.L. Narasimhan","affiliation":["Dept. of Comput. Sci. & Software Eng., Newcastle Univ., Callaghan, NSW, Australia"],"firstName":"V.L.","lastName":"Narasimhan","id":"37850863300"}],"issn":[{"format":"Print ISSN","value":"1045-9219"},{"format":"Electronic ISSN","value":"1558-2183"},{"format":"CD","value":"2161-9883"}],"articleNumber":"1291826","dbTime":"4 ms","metrics":{"wosCitationCount":0,"citationCountPaper":0,"citationCountPatent":0,"totalDownloads":58},"purchaseOptions":{"showOtherFormatPricingTab":false,"showPdfFormatPricingTab":true,"pdfPricingInfoAvailable":true,"otherPricingInfoAvailable":false,"mandatoryBundle":false,"optionalBundle":false,"displayTextWhenOtherFormatPricingNotAvailable":"The purchase and pricing options for this item are unavailable. Select items are only available as part of a subscription package. You may try again later or <a href='https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/contact' target='_blank'>contact us</a> for more information.","pdfPricingInfo":[{"memberPrice":"$14.95","nonMemberPrice":"$33.00","partNumber":"1291826","type":"PDF/HTML"}]},"getProgramTermsAccepted":false,"sections":{"abstract":"true","authors":"true","figures":"false","multimedia":"false","references":"true","citedby":"false","keywords":"true","definitions":"false","algorithm":"false","dataset":"false","cadmore":"false","footnotes":"true","disclaimer":"false","relatedContent":"false","metrics":"true"},"abstract":"Our rebuttal statement is in two parts. A. Generic rebuttal: the area of scheduling is very active with more than 3,000 papers published over this decade alone in good journals. In addition, Krishna and Shin note, in 1997 itself, that the number of papers in the area seems to have increased exponentially since 1970. As a consequence, it is rather difficult to get a handle on all of them.. The records indicate that several aspects of our work appear to be very contemporary to the works of some of the other's work cited by the author. This goes to show that more than one person can have the similar approach to solving similar problems. B. Technical rebuttal: the work quoted by Sohn et al. (1998) deals with the analysis of heterogeneous CPUs. In particular, with the analysis of minimizing the cost (as in $) by selecting the lowest selection of CPUs available that will finish a job in a given time frame. They also analyze the minimum time as well for a given selection of CPUs. Their timeline shows all processes finishing at the same time and does not take into account applications that transfer result data, which our paper does.","publicationDate":"June 2004","pdfPath":"/iel5/71/28775/01291826.pdf","doi":"10.1109/TPDS.2004.12","publicationYear":"2004","pdfUrl":"/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=1291826","publicationTitle":"IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems","formulaStrippedArticleTitle":"Response to \"Comment on 'A Novel Data Distribution Technique for Host-Client Type Parallel Applications\"","displayPublicationTitle":"IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems","startPage":"576","keywords":[{"type":"IEEE Keywords","kwd":["Libraries","Finishing","Australia","Costs","Genetic algorithms","Books","Differential equations","Data compression","Transform coding","Scalability"]}],"displayPublicationDate":"04 May 2004","dateOfInsertion":"04 May 2004","authorNames":"N. Comino;V.L. Narasimhan","doiLink":"https://doi.org/10.1109/TPDS.2004.12","articleCopyRight":"2004 IEEE","rightsLink":"http://s100.copyright.com/AppDispatchServlet?publisherName=ieee&publication=71&title=Response+to+%22Comment+on+%27A+Novel+Data+Distribution+Technique+for+Host-Client+Type+Parallel+Applications%22&isbn=&publicationDate=June+2004&author=N.+Comino&ContentID=10.1109/TPDS.2004.12&orderBeanReset=true&startPage=576&volumeNum=15&issueNum=6","pubLink":"/xpl/RecentIssue.jsp?punumber=71","issueLink":"/xpl/tocresult.jsp?isnumber=28775&punumber=71","allowComments":false,"isGetAddressInfoCaptured":false,"isMarketingOptIn":false,"pubTopics":[{"name":"Computing and Processing"},{"name":"Communication, Networking and Broadcast Technologies"}],"publisher":"IEEE","displayDocTitle":"Response to \"Comment on 'A Novel Data Distribution Technique for Host-Client Type Parallel Applications\"","isOpenAccess":false,"isEphemera":false,"isConference":false,"isPromo":false,"volume":"15","isFreeDocument":false,"isDynamicHtml":true,"isBookWithoutChapters":false,"isEarlyAccess":false,"isSpringer":false,"xploreDocumentType":"Journals & Magazine","isChapter":false,"isProduct":false,"isStandard":false,"isBook":false,"issue":"6","isJournal":true,"isCustomDenial":false,"persistentLink":"https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/servlet/opac?punumber=71","isSAE":false,"isNow":false,"htmlLink":"/document/1291826/","htmlAbstractLink":"/document/1291826/","isSMPTE":false,"isOUP":false,"startPage":"576","articleCopyRight":"2004 IEEE","openAccessFlag":"F","insertDate":"04 May 2004","ephemeraFlag":"false","title":"Response to \"Comment on 'A Novel Data Distribution Technique for Host-Client Type Parallel Applications\"","html_flag":"true","ml_html_flag":"true","sourcePdf":"01291826.pdf","displayPublicationDate":"04 May 2004","mlTime":"PT0.029897S","xplore-pub-id":"71","pdfPath":"/iel5/71/28775/01291826.pdf","sponsors":[{"name":"IEEE Computer Society","url":"http://computer.org/"}],"isNumber":"28775","rightsLinkFlag":"1","contentType":"periodicals","publicationDate":"June 2004","publicationNumber":"71","citationCount":"0","xplore-issue":"28775","issue":"6","articleId":"1291826","publicationTitle":"IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems","sections":{"abstract":"true","authors":"true","figures":"false","multimedia":"false","references":"true","citedby":"false","keywords":"true","definitions":"false","algorithm":"false","dataset":"false","cadmore":"false","footnotes":"true","disclaimer":"false","relatedContent":"false","metrics":"true"},"volume":"15","contentTypeDisplay":"Journals","publicationYear":"2004","subType":"IEEE Transaction","_value":"IEEE","lastupdate":"2024-02-10","mediaPath":"/mediastore_new/IEEE/content/media/71/28775/1291826","displayPublicationTitle":"IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems","doi":"10.1109/TPDS.2004.12"}; </script> <div class="ng2-app">  <div class="global-content-wrapper"> <xpl-root> <div class="Spinner"></div> </xpl-root> </div>    </div> <section id="xploreFooter"> <div class="Footer stats-footer hide-mobile"> <div class="pure-g Footer-sections"> <div class="pure-u-1-4"> <h3 class="Footer-header">IEEE Account</h3> <ul class="Footer-list"> <li><a href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/changeusrpwd/showChangeUsrPwdPage.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore">Change Username/Password</a></li> <li><a href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/address/getAddrInfoPage.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore">Update Address</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="pure-u-1-4"> <h3 class="Footer-header">Purchase Details</h3> <ul class="Footer-list"> <li><a href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/payment/showPaymentHome.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore">Payment Options</a></li> <li><a href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/vieworder/showOrderHistory.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore">Order History</a></li> <li><a href="/articleSale/purchaseHistory.jsp">View Purchased Documents</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="pure-u-1-4"> <h3 class="Footer-header">Profile Information</h3> <ul class="Footer-list"> <li><a href="https://www.ieee.org/ieee-privacyportal/app/ibp?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore">Communications Preferences</a></li> <li><a href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/profedu/getProfEduInformation.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore">Profession and Education</a></li> <li><a href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/tips/getTipsInfo.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore">Technical Interests</a></li> </ul> </div> <div class="pure-u-1-4"> <h3 class="Footer-header">Need Help?</h3> <ul class="Footer-list"> <li><strong>US & Canada:</strong> +1 800 678 4333</li> <li><strong>Worldwide: </strong> +1 732 981 0060<br> </li> <li><a href="/xpl/contact">Contact & Support</a></li> </ul> </div> </div> <div class="row"> <div class="col-12 Footer-bottom"> <div class="Footer-bottom-inner-div row"> <div class="col"> <ul class="Menu Menu--horizontal Menu--dividers u-mb-1"> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="/Xplorehelp/about-ieee-xplore.html">About IEEE <em>Xplore</em></a></li> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="/xpl/contact">Contact Us</a></li> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="/Xplorehelp/Help_start.html" target="blank">Help</a></li> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="/Xplorehelp/accessibility-statement.html" target="blank">Accessibility</a></li> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="/Xplorehelp/Help_Terms_of_Use.html" target="_blank">Terms of Use</a></li> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="http://www.ieee.org/web/aboutus/whatis/policies/p9-26.html">Nondiscrimination Policy</a></li> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="/xpl/sitemap.jsp">Sitemap</a></li> <li class="Menu-item"><a href="http://www.ieee.org/about/help/security_privacy.html" target="blank">Privacy & Opting Out of Cookies</a></li> </ul> <p class="Footer-bottom-terms"> A not-for-profit organization, IEEE is the world's largest technical professional organization dedicated to advancing technology for the benefit of humanity.<br>© Copyright 2024 IEEE - All rights reserved. Use of this web site signifies your agreement to the terms and conditions. </p> </div> <div><i class="logo-ieee-white"></i></div> </div> </div> </div> </div> </section>   <script type ="text/javascript"> // tealium config vars var TEALIUM_CONFIG_TAGGING_ENABLED = true; var TEALIUM_CONFIG_CDN_URL = '//tags.tiqcdn.com/utag/'; var TEALIUM_CONFIG_ACCOUNT_PROFILE_ENV = 'ieeexplore/main/prod'; // tealium utag_data values for user var TEALIUM_userType = 'Anonymous'; var TEALIUM_userInstitutionId = ''; var TEALIUM_userId = ''; var TEALIUM_user_third_party = ''; var TEALIUM_products = ''; </script> <script type="text/javascript"> // asynchronously load tealium's utag.js , which declares tealium JS variables like; utag_data, utag (function(a,b,c,d){ a=TEALIUM_CONFIG_CDN_URL + TEALIUM_CONFIG_ACCOUNT_PROFILE_ENV + '/utag.js'; b=document;c='script';d=b.createElement(c);d.src=a; d.type='text/java'+c;d.async=true; a=b.getElementsByTagName(c)[0];a.parentNode.insertBefore(d,a); })(); </script> <script type="text/javascript" src="/assets/dist/js/analytics/tealiumTagsData.js?cv=20240416_000000"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="/assets/dist/js/analytics/tealiumAnalytics.js?cv=20240416_000000"></script>   <script type="text/javascript" src="/xploreAssets/MathJax-274/MathJax.js?config=default"></script> <link rel="stylesheet" href="/assets/css/ie7Sniffer.css?cv=20240416_000000"> <script type="text/javascript" src="/assets/vendor/js-cookie/src/js.cookie.js?cv=20240416_000000"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="/assets/vendor/fingerprintjs2/fingerprint2.js?cv=20240416_000000"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="/assets/dist/js/fingerprint/fingerprint.js?cv=20240416_000000"></script>  <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/dist/ng-new/runtime.js?cv=20240416_000000' defer charset="utf-8"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/dist/ng-new/polyfills.js?cv=20240416_000000' defer charset="utf-8"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/dist/ng-new/main.js?cv=20240416_000000' defer charset="utf-8"></script>    <script type="text/javascript">/*{literal}<![CDATA[*/window.lightningjs||function(c){function g(b,d){d&&(d+=(/\?/.test(d)?"&":"?")+"lv=1");c[b]||function(){var i=window,h=document,j=b,g=h.location.protocol,l="load",k=0;(function(){function b(){a.P(l);a.w=1;c[j]("_load")}c[j]=function(){function m(){m.id=e;return c[j].apply(m,arguments)}var b,e=++k;b=this&&this!=i?this.id||0:0;(a.s=a.s||[]).push([e,b,arguments]);m.then=function(b,c,h){var d=a.fh[e]=a.fh[e]||[],j=a.eh[e]=a.eh[e]||[],f=a.ph[e]=a.ph[e]||[];b&&d.push(b);c&&j.push(c);h&&f.push(h);return m};return m};var a=c[j]._={};a.fh={};a.eh={};a.ph={};a.l=d?d.replace(/^\/\//,(g=="https:"?g:"http:")+"//"):d;a.p={0:+new Date};a.P=function(b){a.p[b]=new Date-a.p[0]};a.w&&b();i.addEventListener?i.addEventListener(l,b,!1):i.attachEvent("on"+l,b);var q=function(){function b(){return["<head></head><",c,' onload="var d=',n,";d.getElementsByTagName('head')[0].",d,"(d.",g,"('script')).",i,"='",a.l,"'\"></",c,">"].join("")}var c="body",e=h[c];if(!e)return setTimeout(q,100);a.P(1);var d="appendChild",g="createElement",i="src",k=h[g]("div"),l=k[d](h[g]("div")),f=h[g]("iframe"),n="document",p;k.style.display="none";e.insertBefore(k,e.firstChild).id=o+"-"+j;f.frameBorder="0";f.id=o+"-frame-"+j;/MSIE[ ]+6/.test(navigator.userAgent)&&(f[i]="javascript:false");f.allowTransparency="true";l[d](f);try{f.contentWindow[n].open()}catch(s){a.domain=h.domain,p="javascript:var d="+n+".open();d.domain='"+h.domain+"';",f[i]=p+"void(0);"}try{var r=f.contentWindow[n];r.write(b());r.close()}catch(t) { f[i]=p+'d.write("'+b().replace(/"/g,String.fromCharCode(92)+'"')+'");d.close();'}a.P(2)}; a.l&&setTimeout(q,0)})()}();c[b].lv="1";return c[b]}var o="lightningjs",k=window[o]=g(o);k.require=g;k.modules=c}({}); if(!navigator.userAgent.match(/Android|BlackBerry|BB10|iPhone|iPad|iPod|Opera Mini|IEMobile/i)) {window.usabilla_live = lightningjs.require("usabilla_live", "//w.usabilla.com/e9930a118e08.js"); } else {window.usabilla_live = lightningjs.require("usabilla_live", "//w.usabilla.com/118ca38ae742.js"); }/*]]>{/literal}*/</script>   <script type="text/javascript"> (function (w,d,t) { _ml = w._ml || {}; _ml.eid = '82420'; var s, cd, tag; s = d.getElementsByTagName(t)[0]; cd = new Date(); tag = d.createElement(t); tag.async = 1; tag.src = 'https://ml314.com/tag.aspx?' + cd.getDate() + cd.getMonth(); s.parentNode.insertBefore(tag, s); })(window,document,'script'); </script>   <script> (function (){ hum = window.hum || {}; var tracker = { options: { apiKey: 'prod-key-ieee-uqaxhbhwpq', contentSource: 'xplore', apiUrl: 'https://ieee.hum.works/api/', cookieDomain: 'ieee.org', useIframeStorage: true } }; hum['ieee' + 'Tracker'] = tracker; window.hum = hum; hum['ieee' + 'Tracker'].onLoad = () => window.hum = hum; const script = document.createElement('script'); script.src = 'https://ieee.hum.works/js/main.js'; document.head.appendChild(script); }()); </script>  <div style="width: 1263px;" id="popup_overlay"></div> <g:compress> <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/vendor/modernizr/modernizr.js?cv=20240416_000000' charset="utf-8"></script> <script> var $j = jQuery.noConflict(); var j$ = jQuery.noConflict(); var membershipIncomplete; var IS_INDIVIDUAL_USER=false; var searchPropertiesParamQueryText = 'queryText'; var searchPropertiesParamNewSearch = 'newsearch'; var searchPropertiesParamMatchBoolean = 'matchBoolean'; var searchPropertiesParamSearchWithin = 'searchWithin'; var searchInterfaceArticleIndexTermReference = 'Search_Index_Terms'; var searchPropertiesParamRecordsPerPage = 'rowsPerPage'; var searchPropertiesParamPageNumber = 'pageNumber'; var searchPropertiesParamRemoveRefinement = 'removeRefinement'; var searchPropertiesParamSearchField = 'searchField'; var searchPropertiesParamArticleNumber = 'arnumber'; var authorsGetDisplay = 'Authors'; var authorsFirstNameProperty = 'First Name'; var authorsLastNameProperty = 'Last Name'; var authorsMiddleNameProperty = 'Middle Name'; var pubTitleDispNameProperty = 'Publication Title'; var volumeDispNameProperty = 'Volume'; var issueDispNameProperty = 'Issue'; var startPageDispNameProperty = 'Start Page'; var endPageDispNameProperty = 'Start Page'; var searchIcsTermProperty = 'Standards ICS Terms'; var SearchMapperParamSearchField = 'searchField'; var SearchMapperParamNewSearch = 'newsearch'; var SearchMapperParamArticleNumber = 'arnumber'; var NTPT_IMAGE_LOCATION = ''; var XPLORE_SSL_HOST = 'https://ieeexplore.ieee.org'; var SSL_YES_NO = 'yes'; if (SSL_YES_NO.toUpperCase() == "NO"){ var XPLORE_SSL_YES_NO = false; }else{ var XPLORE_SSL_YES_NO = true; } var WEBSERVICES_SSL_YES_NO = 'yes'; if (WEBSERVICES_SSL_YES_NO.toUpperCase() == "NO"){ var XPLORE_WEBSERV_YES_NO = false; }else{ var XPLORE_WEBSERV_YES_NO = true; } var AUTHOR_PROFILE = 'ON'; if (AUTHOR_PROFILE.toUpperCase() == "OFF"){ var AUTHOR_PROFILE_ENABLED = false; }else{ var AUTHOR_PROFILE_ENABLED = true; } var IMAGE_SEARCH_FLAG = 'OFF'; if (IMAGE_SEARCH_FLAG.toUpperCase() == "ON"){ var IMAGE_SEARCH_ENABLED = true; } else { var IMAGE_SEARCH_ENABLED = false; } var ILN_ENABLED = true; var IBP_MEMBEER_SIGNIN_TIME_WAIT_IN_MILLIES = '2800'; var ASSETS_RELATIVE_PATH = '/assets'; // NOTE: AngularJS code relies on this var ASSETS_RELATIVE_PATH_NO_SERVER = '/assets'; var ASSETS_VERSION = '20240416_000000'; // NOTE: AngularJS code relies on this var IBP_WS_ASSETS='https://www.ieee.org'; var IBP_WS_ENABLED_FLAG = true; var ENTERPRISE_CART_URL = 'https://www.ieee.org/cart/public/myCart/page.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE%20Xplore'; var IEEE_USER_INFO_COOKIE = 'ieeeUserInfoCookie'; var ACC_MGMT_NEW = true; if (! XPLORE_WEBSERV_YES_NO) { var ACC_MGMT_NEW = 'false'; } var ACC_MGMT_CREATE_URL = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/createwebaccount/showCreateAccount.html?ShowMGAMarkeatbilityOptIn=true&sourceCode=xplore&car=IEEE-Xplore&autoSignin=Y'; var ACC_MGMT_FORGOT_PASSWD_URL = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/forgotpassword/forgotUsernamePassword.html?sourceCode=xplore'; var SPECIAL_CHARACTER_MAPS = '&:.AND.,=:.EQ.,+:.PLS.,#:.HSH.'; var SPECIAL_CHARACTERS = new Array(); var SPECIAL_CHARACTER_REPLACEMENTS = new Array(); var characterMaps = SPECIAL_CHARACTER_MAPS.split(","); for (var i = 0; i < characterMaps.length; i++) { parts = characterMaps[i].split(":"); SPECIAL_CHARACTERS[i] = parts[0]; SPECIAL_CHARACTER_REPLACEMENTS[i] = parts[1]; } var MAX_WILDCARDS = '9'; var MAX_SEARCH_TERMS = '25'; var ALL_SEARCH_FIELDS = 'Search_Index_Terms:Index Terms,Search_All_Text:Full Text & Metadata,Search_All:All Metadata,fullText:Full Text Only,Search_Publication_Title:Search Publication Title,Search_Related_Terms:Search Related Terms,Search_Authors:Author Name,Search_Standard_Ics_Title:ICE Terms,promoTopic:Custom Search,id:Article Number,moduleNumber:Module Number,part_num:Part_Num,issn:ISSN,isbn:ISBN,eisbn:EISBN,issueId:IS Number,pubIssueId:Pub Issue Id,accessionNumber:Accession Number,copyrightHolder:Copyright Holder,copyrightYear:Copyright Year,license:License,documentAbstract:Abstract,publicationId:Publication Number,parentPublicationId:Parent Publication Number,parentId:Parent Id,standardArticleId:Standard Article Id,title:Document Title,parentTitle:Parent Publication Title,parentDisplayTitle:Parent Display Title,publicationTitle:Publication Title,publicationDisplayTitle:Publication Display Title,volume:Volume,issue:Issue,paddedIssueNumber:Padded Issue Number,part:Part,startPage:Start Page,endPage:End Page,filePath:File Path,publicationDate:Publication Date,PublicationYear:Publication Year,onlineDate:Online Date,month:Month,Author:Author Pref Names,authorNormNames:Author Norm Names,author:Authors,authorIds:Author Ids,firstName:First Name,middleName:Middle Name,lastName:Last Name,authorAffiliations:Author Affiliations,authorBio:Author Bio,authorImg:Author Img,referenceCount:Reference Count,citationCount:Citation Count,downloadCount:Download Count,patentCount:Patent Count,multimediaFlag:Multimedia Flag,biomedicalEngFlag:Biomedical Eng Flag,nonIeee:Non IEEE,stdsProductNumber:STDS Product Number,bmsProductNumber:Bms Product Number,status:Status,doi:DOI,articleDoi:Article DOI,publicationDoi:Publication DOI,pdfPath:Pdf Path,pdfSize:Pdf Size,contentSubtype:Content Subtype,Publisher:Publisher,inspecControlledTerms:INSPEC Controlled Terms,ieeeTerms:IEEE Terms,unsiloTerms:Unsilo Terms,authorTerms:Author Keywords,maiTerms:MAI Terms,meshTerms:Mesh_Terms,pacsTerms:PACS Terms,insertDate:Insert Date,ConferenceLocation:Conference Location,indexContent:Index Content,coden:CODEN,documentText:Document Text,standardNumber:Standard Number,preprintFlag:Preprint Flag,rapidPostFlag:Rapid Post Flag,lastUpdate:Last Update,newFlag:New Flag,openAccessFlag:Open Access Flag,publicationOpenAccess:Publication Open Access,promoFlag:Promo Flag,pubmedId:Pubmed Id,duration:Duration,society:Society,conference:Conference,ConferenceCountry:ConferenceCountry,conferenceStartDate:Conference Start Date,conferenceEndDate:Conference End Date,societyUrl:Society URL,idSubject:Id Subject,bookNumber:Book Number,pages:Pages,editionNumber:Edition Number,sequence:Sequence,relatedInfoType:Related Info Type,relatedInfo:Related Info,formatIsbn:Format ISBN,meetingDate:Meeting Date,courseLevel:Course level,courseParts:Course Parts,courseId:Course ID,aboutUrl:About Url,additionalUrl:Additional Url,authorsUrl:Authors Url,openAccessUrl:Open Access Url,openAccessFlag:Open Access flag,partnumVendorurlMediatype:Partnum VendorURL MediaType,brandingImageFile:Branding Image File,coverImageFile:Cover Image File,latestIssueCoverImage:Latest Issue Cover Image,frequency:Frequency,fieldOfInterest:Field Of Interest,gParentPublicationNumber:G Parent Publication Number,msUrl:Ms Url,publicationRelationship:Relationship,societyImage:Society Image,visitUrl:Visit Url,visitWebsite:Visit Website,startYear:Start Year,endYear:End Year,publicationInactive:Publication Inactive,recordType:Record Type,picCodeDescription:Pic Code Description,picCode:Pic Code,sponsors:Sponsors,issueNotes:Notes,conferenceDate:Conference Date,publicationContact:Publication Contact,isbuyable:isBuyable,standardRelationships:Standard Relationships,unavailableForSale:Unavailable for Sale,availableForSale:Available for Sale,standardFamily:Standard Family,standardGroup:Standard Group,productUrl:Product Url,isbnMediatype:ISBN MediaType,htmlFlag:Html Flag,rightslinkFlag:Rightslink Flag,pageCount:Page Count,name:Name,tableOfContents:Table of Contents,timeStamp:Time Stamp,subTitle:Sub Title,relatedItem:Related Item,referenceMaterial:Reference Material,latestIssueTime:Latest Issue Time,startYear:First Published Year,insertDate:Search Latest Date,pbdFlag:Pbd Flag,lmsUrl:Lms Url,currentVolume:Current Volume,graphicalFile:Graphical File,graphicalCoverImage:Graphical Cover Image,graphicalSummary:Graphical Summary,graphicalType:Graphical Type,graphicalAbstractFile:Graphical Abstract File,graphicalAbstractImage:Graphical Abstract Image,graphicalAbstractType:Graphical Abstract Type,graphicalAbstractSummary:Graphical Abstract Summary,authorNativeNames:Native Name,externalId:Article Page Number,standardBundles:Standard Bundles,standardBundleParts:Standard Bundle Parts,virtualTitle:Virtual Title,seriesName:Series Name,seriesId:Series Id,mlHtmlFlag:ML Html flag,promoDates:Promo Dates,promoStartDate:Promo Start Date,promoEndDate:Promo End Date,issueCompleteFlag:Issue Complete Flag,scope:Scope,purpose:Purpose,standardFamilyTitle:Standard Family Title,thumbnailImg:Thumbnail Img,supplementFile:Supplement File,courseFile:Course File,supplement:Supplement,courseAuthor:Course Author,pdhs:Pdhs,ceus:Ceus,courseFirstFrame:FirstFrame Img,idSubTopic:Id Sub Topic,certificateUrl:Certificate Url,standardRoot:Standard Root,icsTerms:Standards ICS Terms,impactStatement:Impact Statement,affirmedDate:Affirmed Date,sourcePdf:Source Pdf,orcid:Author ORCID,algorithmFlag:Algorithm Flag,fundingAgency:Funding Agency,funder:Funder,pricingKey:Map Pricing Key,publicationRollup:Rollup Key,collection:Collection,previewImage:Preview Image,regularDate:Regular Date,ContentType:Content Type,ringgoldIds:Ringgold ID,figure:Figure,mediaPath:Media Path,publicationVolumeOnly:Publication Volume Only,Search_All:All Metadata,Search_All_Text:Full Text & Metadata,fullText:Full Text Only,TypeAheadTerms:Type Ahead Terms,ContentType:Content Type,Author:Author,Affiliation:Affiliation,Topic:Topic,PublicationTitle:Publication Title,PublicationYear:Year,Publisher:Publisher,ConferenceCountry:Conference Country,ConferenceLocation:Conference Location,StandardStatus:Standard Status,ConferenceYear:Conference Year,PublicationPackage:Subscribed Content,StandardPackage:Standard Package,ReadingRoom:Reading Room,StandardTitle:Standard Title,StdDictionaryTerms:Standards Dictionary Terms,TitleRange:Publication Range,StandardRange:Standard Range,RecordType:Record Type,MediaType:Media Type,BookType:Book Type,CourseType:Course Type,PublicationStandardRange:Publication Standard Range,PerpetualYear:Perpetual Year,OpacTitleRange:Opac Title Range,BookSeries:Book Series,SubjectCategory:Subject Category,Sessions:Sessions,TypeAheadPublication:Type Ahead Publication,SubTopic:Sub Topic,CourseDuration:Course Duration,CourseLevel:Course Level,StandardType:Standard Type,StandardSubtype:Standard SubType,StandardModifier:Standard Modifier,IcsTerms1:Ics Terms 1,IcsTerms2:Ics Terms 2,IcsTerms3:Ics Terms 3,SupplementalItem:Supplemental Items,CourseDuration:Course Duration,SpecialSection:Topics,SocietySection:Society Sections,PublicationTopics:Publication Topics,Keywords:Keywords'; var SEARCH_FIELD_REFERENCES = new Array(); var SEARCH_FIELD_DISPLAYS = new Array(); var searchFields = ALL_SEARCH_FIELDS.split(","); for (var j = 0; j < searchFields.length; j++) { parts = searchFields[j].split(":"); SEARCH_FIELD_REFERENCES[j] = parts[0]; SEARCH_FIELD_DISPLAYS[j] = parts[1]; } var refSite='https://ieeexplore.ieee.org'; var refSiteName="IEEE Xplore"; var applicationName = 'Xplore'; var MC_OPERATION_DELAY_TIMEOUT='5000'; var MC_ADDING_DELAY_MSG='Please wait.The selected item(s) is being added to the cart.'; var MC_TIMEOUT='60000'; var MC_OPERATION_DELAY_MSG_FLAG='true'; var MEMBER_PROFILE_CHANGE_USERNAMEPASS_LINK = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/changeusrpwd/showChangeUsrPwdPage.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var MEMBER_MY_PROFILE ='https://www.ieee.org/profile/myprofile/myprofile.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var MEMBER_PROFILE_ADDRESSINFO_LINK = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/address/getAddrInfoPage.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var MEMBER_PROFILE_PAYMENTINFO_LINK = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/payment/showPaymentHome.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var MEMBER_PROFILE_ORDER_HISTORY_LINK = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/vieworder/showOrderHistory.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var MEMBER_USER_COMMUNICATION_LINK = 'https://www.ieee.org/ieee-privacyportal/app/ibp?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var MEMBER_EDUCATIONAL_PROFILE_LINK = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/profedu/getProfEduInformation.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var MEMBER_TECHNICAL_INTERESTS_LINK = 'https://www.ieee.org/profile/tips/getTipsInfo.html?refSite=https://ieeexplore.ieee.org&refSiteName=IEEE Xplore'; var HELPFILE_RELATIVE_PATH = '/Xplorehelp'; //content types var CONTENT_TYPE_PARAM = 'contentType'; var CONTENT_TYPE_BOOKS = 'Books'; var CONTENT_TYPE_COURSES = 'Courses'; var CONTENT_TYPE_STANDARDS = 'Standards'; var CONTENT_TYPE_CONFERENCES = 'Conferences'; var CONTENT_TYPE_JOURNALS = 'Journals'; var CONTENT_TYPE_EARLY_ACCESS = 'Early Access Articles'; //User Preferences var citFormat = ""; var dlFormat = ""; var myProjectLimit = 15; var myProjectDocumentLimit = 1000; var myProjectDocumentTagLimit = 50; //Google ReCaptcha public Key var RECAPTCHA_PUBLIC_KEY = '6Ld6GEUUAAAAALdaAmeGUhZyz1KFFHnd5oCaTW-t'; var seamlessAccessPersistenceUrl = 'https://service.seamlessaccess.org/ps/'; </script> <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/dist/js/history.js?cv=20240416_000000' charset="utf-8"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/dist/js/cart/cartScroll.js?cv=20240416_000000' charset="utf-8"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/dist/js/cart/minicart.js?cv=20240416_000000' charset="utf-8"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='/assets/dist/js/master.js?cv=20240416_000000' charset="utf-8"></script> <script> j$('document').ready(function(){ if (Cookies.get('legacyUserName')) { if (IBP_WS_ENABLED_FLAG){ Modal.refreshLegacyAccountTransition('/xpl/mwLegacyAccountTransition.jsp'); } } }); </script> </g:compress> <script> // Get/Set XPL namespace. window.xpl = window.xpl || {}; // Set constants/application properties. xpl.properties = { collabratec: { url: 'https://ieee-collabratec.ieee.org/app/library' } }; xpl.properties.details = { oqs: '' }; </script>  <script type="text/javascript" src='https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/common/jquery.json-2.2.min.js'></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/common/postmessage-min.js" ></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/common/jquery.cookie-min.js'></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/auth/ieee-auth-constants-min.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/auth/ieee-auth-include-min.js" ></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/minicart/ieee-mini-cart-constants-min.js'></script> <script type="text/javascript" src='https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/minicart/ieee-mashup-util-min.js'></script> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/common/jquery.ba-jqmq-min.js"></script> <script type="text/javaScript" src="https://www.ieee.org/ieee-mashup/js/minicart/ieee-minicart-include-min.js"> </script>      <script defer> MathJax.Hub.Queue(["Typeset", MathJax.Hub, document.body]); </script> <script> window.PARSELY = window.PARSELY || { use_localstorage: true }; </script> <script id="parsely-cfg" src="//cdn.parsely.com/keys/ieeexplore.ieee.org/p.js"></script> </div> </div> <script> // set $ alias back to jQuery because noConflict mode is used in legacy pages window.$ = jQuery; </script> </div> </body> </html>